80% of shoppers say they stopped shopping at a retailer after it changed its return policy, according to Optoro’s 2024 Returns Unwrapped survey of 573 US consumers, a figure up 35% since 2023. Fees now touch most mailed returns: 63% of retailers charge one, and named national fees range from roughly $4 to $12 per package.
That gap, retailers adding fees to recover cost and shoppers punishing them for it, is the entire story below. Here is what the current data says about who charges, how much, why, and what it costs a retailer in return.
How many retailers charge for returns in 2026?
63% of US retail executives say their company charges a shipping or restocking fee on at least one type of return, according to Optoro’s 2024 Returns Unwrapped survey of 350 US retail executives. Of the retailers still offering free returns, 55% said they are considering adding a fee, which suggests the current share understates where the market is headed.
Figure 1: Share of US retail executives who say their company charges a return fee. Source: Optoro, 2024 Returns Unwrapped, survey of 350 US retail executives.
A separate, larger National Retail Federation and Happy Returns survey found the share climbed to 72% of retailers in 2025, up from 66% in 2024. The two surveys use different panels and question wording, so the numbers are not a single continuous series, but both point the same direction. For the full prevalence trend and category breakdown, see our free returns breakdown.
How much does a paid return actually cost shoppers?
Fees vary widely by retailer. Among national chains reported in late-2025 holiday return-fee roundups, H&M charged $3.99 per mailed return, Zara $4.95, American Eagle $5, J.Crew $7.50, JCPenney $8, and Marshalls and T.J. Maxx $11.99, deducted directly from the refund. Most of these retailers still offer free returns in a physical store, so the fee is specifically a mail-in charge.
Figure 2: Mailed-return fee amounts at named national retailers. T.J. Maxx charges the same $11.99 as sister chain Marshalls. Source: 2025 holiday return-fee roundups, including ABC7 Chicago (December 2025).
Macy’s deducts roughly $9.99 from a refund for non-loyalty members who mail a return. The pattern across every retailer above is the same: the fee only applies to a prepaid mail-in label, and it disappears if a shopper drives to a store instead. The total cost of return shipping across the industry, as distinct from what an individual retailer charges a shopper, is its own separate and still-developing data story worth watching in 2026.
What do restocking fees look like?
Restocking fees are a separate charge from a mailed-return shipping fee, and they scale with the item’s price rather than a flat dollar amount. Best Buy charges 15% on opened electronics such as drones, cameras, and camera lenses, plus a flat $45 fee on activatable devices like phones and tablets. Kohl’s charges 15% on eligible returns unless the item is defective. JCPenney charges 15% to 20% plus an $85 pickup fee on large furniture returns, and Walmart says some third-party marketplace sellers may charge up to 20% on categories such as major appliances and furniture.
| Retailer | Fee type | Amount |
|---|---|---|
| Best Buy | Restocking, opened electronics | 15% |
| Best Buy | Flat fee, activatable devices | $45 |
| Kohl’s | Restocking, non-defective items | 15% |
| JCPenney | Restocking plus pickup, furniture | 15% to 20% plus $85 |
| Walmart marketplace | Restocking, third-party sellers | Up to 20% |
Source: retailer return-policy pages, as reported in 2025 holiday return-fee coverage.
A restocking fee that a shopper only discovers at the return counter is the fastest way to turn a routine return into a dispute. Publishing the fee, the percentage, and the categories it applies to inside a clear refund policy gives staff a documented number to point to instead of negotiating one on the spot.
Why are retailers charging for returns now?
Retailers are not shy about the reason: it is cost, not customer experience. Among the 350 retail executives Optoro surveyed, 54% said they are actively looking for ways to increase the financial recovery from returns, 39% said a fee was added specifically to discourage excessive or abusive returns, and 20% said the goal is simply to make returns harder or less appealing. Optoro’s research also found that processing an average return costs retailers about 27% of the item’s purchase price, which can erase up to half the sale’s margin.
Figure 3: How a typical return moves from initiation to a fee, or no fee, based on the policies described above. Source: synthesized from the named retailer policies in this article.
For the wider set of reasons retailers cite, including shipping costs and tariff pressure, and for the online return-rate context those fees sit inside, our ecommerce return rate breakdown covers the 19.3% online return rate and the $849.9 billion total return figure in full.
How do shoppers react to paying for returns?
Shoppers are not adjusting quietly. 57.67% of the 573 consumers Optoro surveyed named the fee itself as the single most frustrating part of making a return, ahead of every other complaint about the process. 75.44% admitted to embellishing or exaggerating their reason for a return specifically to avoid triggering a fee, a sharp rise from the prior year. On the loyalty side, 84% of shoppers said they had chosen one retailer over another specifically because of a better return policy, up 20 percentage points from 2023.
Figure 4: How shoppers say they respond to return fees and return policy changes. Source: Optoro, 2024 Returns Unwrapped, survey of 573 US consumers.
| Shopper reaction | Share reporting it |
|---|---|
| Stopped shopping at a retailer after a policy change | 80% |
| Chose one retailer over another for its return policy | 84% |
| Embellished a return reason to avoid a fee | 75.44% |
| Called the fee the most frustrating part of a return | 57.67% |
Source: Optoro, 2024 Returns Unwrapped, retailer and consumer surveys.
None of these four numbers moves in a retailer’s favor. A policy built to recover cost is also, by the same survey, actively pushing a majority of shoppers toward whichever competitor still makes returns easy.
Do shoppers check the return policy before buying?
Fee awareness starts before checkout for most online shoppers. 81% of US digital shoppers say they review a retailer’s return policy before making a first purchase, and 73% say a poor returns experience affects whether they shop with that retailer again, according to Narvar’s survey of 1,924 US consumers ages 18 to 75. The same research found 39% of consumers return an online purchase at least once a month, so the return policy is not a one-time read for most shoppers, it is a recurring checkpoint.
Figure 5: Milestones in return-fee prevalence and shopper reaction, 2023 to 2025. Sources: Optoro, 2024 Returns Unwrapped; National Retail Federation and Happy Returns, 2025 Retail Returns Landscape.
A shopper who checks the policy before buying and a shopper who quietly stops buying after a fee shows up are the same person at two different points in the funnel. A policy that is easy to find and plainly worded addresses both moments at once.
The Bottom Line
The number that should worry a retailer weighing a new fee is not the fee’s revenue, it is 80%, the share of shoppers who say they actually left after a policy change rather than merely disliking it. Fees are spreading because the cost math favors them: 63% of retailers already charge one, restocking fees commonly run 15% to 20%, and named national fees cluster between $4 and $12 per package. But the same surveys that show retailers recovering cost also show 57.67% of shoppers naming the fee as their top frustration and 75.44% bending the truth to avoid one. A clear, specific refund policy that states the fee, the percentage, and the exceptions before checkout will not make a fee popular, but it removes the surprise that turns a fee into a lost customer.
Frequently Asked Questions
What percentage of retailers charge a return fee in 2026? 63% of US retail executives say their company charges a shipping or restocking fee on at least one type of return, and 55% of the holdouts are considering adding one, according to Optoro’s 2024 Returns Unwrapped survey of 350 retail executives. A separate National Retail Federation and Happy Returns survey put the broader figure at 72% of retailers in 2025, up from 66% in 2024.
How much do retailers charge for a mailed return? Named national retailers charged between $3.99 and $11.99 per mailed return package during the 2025 holiday season: H&M at $3.99, Zara at $4.95, American Eagle at $5, J.Crew at $7.50, JCPenney at $8, and Marshalls and T.J. Maxx at $11.99, according to holiday return-fee roundups published in late 2025.
How do shoppers react when a retailer starts charging for returns? 80% of shoppers say they stopped shopping at a retailer after it changed its return policy, up 35% since 2023, and 57.67% call the fee the most frustrating part of making a return, according to Optoro’s 2024 Returns Unwrapped survey of 573 US consumers.
What is a typical restocking fee percentage? Restocking fees commonly run 15% to 20% of an item’s price. Best Buy and Kohl’s both charge 15% on eligible items, and JCPenney charges 15% to 20% plus an $85 pickup fee on large furniture returns.
Sources and References
- Optoro. (2024). “Returns Unwrapped: Comparing Retailer and Shopper Perspectives.” Survey of 573 US consumers and 350 US retail executives, ages 18+.
- Optoro. (2024). “Returns Unwrapped: Comparing Retailer and Shopper Perspectives” (blog summary). Same survey as above.
- National Retail Federation and Happy Returns. (2025). “2025 Retail Returns Landscape.” Retailer survey of 358 ecommerce professionals; total returns projected at $849.9 billion.
- ABC7 Chicago. (2025, December 27). “More companies charging restocking fees this year than last as many make returns after Christmas.” Named retailer fee amounts for Marshalls, T.J. Maxx, Macy’s, JCPenney, and J.Crew.
- Narvar. (2024). “State of Returns 2024 Report.” Survey of 1,924 US consumers ages 18 to 75.
Note: All figures verified as of November 2026. Return-fee policy and shopper reaction data shift quickly with each holiday season, so headline figures here are scheduled for a refresh at least twice a year.








