A general non-compete enforceability check, does the state ban them outright, restrict them by income, or apply a plain reasonableness test, does not fully answer the question for a medical practice. A separate layer of state law singles out physicians, and in a few states other licensed healthcare providers too, for treatment that is stricter than what applies to a sales director or a software engineer under the exact same contract template. A practice that reuses a standard employment non-compete for a physician hire is applying the wrong rulebook, and in several states that mistake voids the clause entirely.
Why Healthcare Providers Get Separate Treatment
The reasoning legislatures give for singling out physicians is consistent across states: a non-compete that keeps a doctor from practicing nearby does not just affect the doctor’s income, it affects every patient who would otherwise follow that doctor to a new practice, and in rural or underserved areas it can functionally remove a specialty from the area entirely. That public health interest is different from the ordinary trade-secret or client-relationship interest a non-compete protects in most industries, and it is why physician non-competes get their own statute in a growing number of states rather than falling under the same reasonableness test as everyone else.
States That Ban Physician Non-Competes Outright
A handful of states void non-compete agreements against physicians specifically, separate from any general non-compete ban that state might also have.
Massachusetts banned non-compete agreements between physicians and their employer or practice under General Laws Chapter 112, Section 12X, a law that predates the state’s broader 2018 Noncompetition Agreement Act, which itself separately excludes physicians from its coverage. Rhode Island voids non-compete agreements for physicians under its general laws as well. Delaware enacted a law in 2023 voiding non-compete covenants for physicians in the state. Pennsylvania’s Fair Contracting for Health Care Practitioners Act bars non-competes for physicians, along with several other covered healthcare practitioner types, in contracts entered on or after January 1, 2025, with a narrow exception for practice buyouts and departures with advance notice.
New Mexico’s ban, in effect since 2022, goes further than a physician-only carve-out: it voids non-compete agreements for healthcare practitioners generally, a category that includes physicians, dentists, chiropractors, and other licensed providers, not just doctors. That makes New Mexico an outlier worth flagging separately from states whose special rule only reaches physicians by title.
It is also worth remembering that the four states with a general non-compete ban, California, North Dakota, Oklahoma, and Minnesota, cover physicians automatically as part of that broader ban. Our state-by-state non-compete enforceability guide covers that general landscape in full; the states below are the ones that carve physicians out specifically, on top of whatever the general rule in that state already is.
States That Allow Physician Non-Competes With Conditions
A second, larger group of states does not ban physician non-competes but attaches conditions that do not apply to a standard employee non-compete in the same state.
Texas is the clearest example. Business and Commerce Code Section 15.50(b) allows physician non-competes only if the agreement provides a reasonable buy-out price the physician can pay to exit the restriction, gives the physician access to a list of patients they treated in the year before termination, and carves out continuing care for patients with an acute illness for a defined period after departure. A Texas physician non-compete missing any one of those three elements is not automatically enforceable the way a missing clause in an ordinary employee non-compete might still partly survive.
Figure 1: The three terms a Texas physician non-compete must contain. Source: Texas Business and Commerce Code Section 15.50(b).
Colorado voids physician non-competes as a general matter, but its statute preserves the parts of the underlying agreement that require payment of damages reasonably related to the injury caused by the physician’s departure, and it requires the departing physician’s employer to notify affected patients of their right to continued care and the physician’s forwarding information. Connecticut caps physician non-competes at one year in duration and 15 miles in geographic radius, and voids the clause outright if the physician was terminated without cause or the employer chose not to renew the underlying contract. Tennessee requires a buy-out provision, patient list access, and a carve-out for patients with emergent conditions, on top of its own duration and geography limits. Indiana’s 2023 law bars non-compete agreements for primary care physicians in contracts entered or renewed after that law took effect, while non-primary-care physicians remain subject to non-competes only if the contract provides patient list access, notice of the physician’s departure, and a treatment carve-out for patients with acute conditions.
Figure 2: Connecticut’s ceiling on a physician non-compete, per the state’s physician non-compete statute.
Physician Non-Compete State Approaches
| Outright Ban | Conditional Rules | No Special Rule | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Example states | MA, RI, DE, PA, NM | TX, CO, CT, TN, IN | Most other states |
| Physician non-compete valid at all | |||
| Requires patient list or buy-out | |||
| Reasonableness test still applies |
Every state not listed in either column defaults to treating a physician non-compete the same as any other employee non-compete, subject to the general reasonableness test on scope, duration, and geography covered in the enforceability guide linked above. That default is common, not the exception, so confirming whether a physician-specific statute exists at all is the first step, not an assumption that one does.
Working Through the Question for a Given State
What a Compliant Physician Non-Compete Actually Includes
Where a state permits a physician non-compete at all, the clauses that separate an enforceable version from a voided one are the same three elements that show up across most of the conditional states: a way for the physician to exit the restriction by paying a defined amount rather than being locked in indefinitely, continued access to the list of patients they treated so those patients are not simply abandoned, and an explicit carve-out letting the physician keep treating a patient with an acute or ongoing condition for a defined window after departure, since forcing an active patient to find a new physician mid-treatment is exactly the harm these statutes are written to prevent.
- "Physician may not practice medicine within 50 miles for 3 years"
- "No provision addressing patient continuity of care"
- "No buy-out or exit option provided"
- "Non-compete narrowed to a defined service area and 1 to 2 year term"
- "Patient list access and a continuing-care carve-out included"
- "Buy-out provision lets the physician pay a set amount to exit early"
A non-compete drafted for a general employee and handed to a physician hire is the most common way this goes wrong in practice, not bad faith, just a template built for the wrong category of worker. The rest of the physician’s employment agreement, compensation structure, malpractice coverage responsibility, and termination terms still needs to be drafted correctly alongside the non-compete clause; What to Include in an Employment Contract covers that surrounding structure. Building the non-compete language itself, matched to whether a given state bans it, conditions it, or applies the ordinary reasonableness test, is what the Non-Compete Agreement generator is built to do, rather than starting from language written for a different profession.
The Practical Takeaway
A practice hiring a physician in a new state should check three things before reusing a non-compete template: whether that state bans physician non-competes outright, whether it imposes physician-specific conditions like a buy-out or patient list requirement, and only after both of those come back clear, whether the clause’s scope, duration, and geography would pass the ordinary reasonableness test. Skipping straight to the third question is the mistake that produces a non-compete a practice believes protects it and a court simply will not enforce.








